Student of the Market

1. Stocks have continued higher regardless of presidential party:
As elections come up, we tend to get concerned about which party might be better for the market. Historically, the market has continued to rise, regardless of which party is in the White House. Since 1926, $1,000 invested in the S&P 500 would have grown to $8.96m as of 6/30/20, with a number of regime changes along the way.

2. U.S. Stocks across the election cycle: Stocks have historically performed above average in presidential election years. However, they’ve also tended to post their strongest performance in years where there is no presidential or midterm election.

3. Investors build cash in election years (especially this year) During presidential election years, there are usually greater inflows into money market funds than in years with no presidential election. This election year has seen historically large flows, due to the combined effect of the election and coronavirus pandemic.

4. Divided governments and the U.S. stock market: Stock markets tend to post stronger performance when the White House and Congress are controlled by the same party, on average. We have seen this happen roughly half of all presidential terms throughout history.

5. Stocks across a presidential term: Over a president’s term, the third year is often the highest performing year for the stock market. If a president is lucky enough to be elected to a second term, stock returns tend to reflect those of the first term (roughly 12% on average for each term).

6. New vs. incumbent presidents: On average, stocks have historically performed better in election years where an incumbent president wins reelection (13.4%) than when a new president is elected (9.3%).

7. Asset class performance in presidential election years: This year, we’re seeing asset classes performing much differently than their historical average in election years.

8. Market seasonality in election years: On average, the period known as “Mommies to Mummies” (May 1 to October 31) have historically performed worse than the period known as “Turkey to Tax” (November 1 to April 30). In election years, however, “Mommies to Mummies” tends to perform better than average, and “Turkey to Tax” tends to perform worse.

 

Read the next post in our Special Election Edition series:
Elections Matter But Not So Much to Your Investments

 

 

 

Source: Morningstar as of 6/30/20. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Index performance is shown for illustrative purposes only. You cannot invest directly in an index.